US Supreme Court Stands By Opening Prayers For Legislative Meetings

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

The Supreme Court handed down a ruling in favor of Christian prayer at legislative meetings on Monday morning.

That means its ok for groups like city councils and county commissions to start meetings off with a prayer.

Two people from New York sued saying a specifically Christian prayer before town council meetings violated the constitution.

We've seen these issues here in the Valley too - both the Madison County Commission and Huntsville City Council got letters from an atheist group about their pre-meeting prayers.

We visited attorney Rebekah McKinney to get her to help break down the decision that she spent the morning rifling through.

After examining the ruling, McKinney says those opening prayers stand up under the court's decision - as long as attendees or public officials don't have to participate, "The government cannot require religion of a specific type, and they cannot require that you endure it without violating the First Amendment."

The court ruling says frankly, it doesn't matter if the prayers offend people.

McKinney notes, "There's a lot of things in this world that offend people about speech, and you see that time and again with things that have been held to be acceptable under the First Amendment, though they may offend you, that does not make them unlawful."

Now members of the court did specify that prayers couldn't attack or attempt to convert, but they can certainly open a meeting.

McKinney adds that she thinks the ruling will apply to school board meetings as well.

However, she says some of the language may prevent it from extending to all prayers at school events.

You can read the full ruling here.


  • johnny

    I think they should have opening prayer,ask GOD to clear there minds and help them in their decision making.This country needs to get back on track.If someone doesn’t want to pray they don’t have to join in.

    • Say What

      You stated that, “If someone doesn’t want to pray they don’t have to join in.” Will you say that when a city council has a Muslim Chairman that wants to start the meeting with an Islamic prayer?

  • Dane Parker

    Say What,

    That’s an easy one. Yes. I wouldn’t be surprised if this has occurred in Dearborn, MI for example. But who cares? It reflects the people’s beliefs and center of conscience.

      • Dane Parker

        I’m sorry; are you suggesting I was lying, and that you read minds such that you would even know?

      • Say What

        No, I am suggesting that it is easy to answer a hypothetical, until it becomes a reality — than things may be very different!

Comments are closed.

Notice: you are using an outdated browser. Microsoft does not recommend using IE as your default browser. Some features on this website, like video and images, might not work properly. For the best experience, please upgrade your browser.