Decatur Lawsuit Threatens Developments, Projects

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

DECATUR, Ala. (WHNT) - The Sweetwater Development Project in Decatur that includes a Bass Pro Shop could all be in jeopardy because of a lawsuit that challenges Decatur's form of government. Voters in Decatur elected nearly four years ago to switch to a council-manager form of government. but the city never made the change, saying it would violate the federal Voting Rights Act. Now, a lawsuit that seeks to force the change is threatening the Sweetwater deal and a host of other projects.

Originally city officials didn't seem too concerned about the suit, at least not publicly. But court documents obtained by WHNT News 19 reveal what a headache the lawsuit has become and explains why the city wants a ruling on the matter as quickly as possible.

An affidavit filed in federal court on the behalf of Decatur Mayor Don Kyle says allegations in the lawsuit that the mayor and city council are holding office unlawfully have caused uncertainty among financial institutions, attorneys and others involved in economic development projects. The brief describes the lawsuit as "problematic" with regards to the proposed Sweetwater Development Project. It also says Decatur Utilities has been stopped from using a bank line of credit until the lawsuit is settled.

The mayor also says in the affidavit that day-to-day operations of the city are potentially adversely affected with regards to purchase orders and other lesser contracts the city may execute.

The lawsuit seeks to force the city to change from a mayor-council form of government to a council-manager form, wherein the mayor would become a parttime official and the day-to-day operation of the city would be handled by a city manager. Voters in Decatur approved that change in 2010. But city officials never implemented it saying it would violate the Voting Rights Act by reducing the number of districts from five to three, and eliminate the one predominately black voter district that Decatur currently has.

Mayor Kyle did not yet return our calls, but an attorney for the Alabama League of Municipalities says those doing business with the city should not be overly concerned because "courts typically don't go back and un-do what council members have done in good faith." Still, Lori Lein admits bond attorneys, like those who would be involved in the Sweetwater development, would be skeptical to approve the deal while the city is involved in a lawsuit over who will actually run the city.

Carl Cole, the attorney representing the Decatur man who filed the lawsuit, told WHNT News 19, "I think there's a level of incompetance there about what's going on with this case and how it could affect things. They've gotten some people in now that I think have told them this is a bigger deal than you think."

The city has hired outside attorneys to handle the suit for them, and both sides have filed motions for a summary judgement, that is essentially to have the case decided without a trial. No trial date has been set but a conference hearing has been scheduled for Friday, and on Monday the city council is scheduled to vote on the Sweetwater proposal. Of course, we'll let you know what happens.


  • Nuclear Mike

    The voters of Decatur spoke some years ago at the voting booths and still the City Government will not yield its’ power…time for more lawsuits!!!

  • magpiper

    Difficult to pry the power from a few when the masses require it. This is one instance where Hartselle is actually ahead of Decatur.

  • Local

    Looks like Bass Pro, like everything else, may land in Huntsville. The residents of Decatur are going to feel dumb when it happens. They’ll be left pointing fingers at each other. This could be a good thing, if it goes.

  • Turd Fergsuon

    Just like everything else in the Ghetto…I mean River City….Grand Opening/Grand Closing.

  • Debra

    It figures that they will lay the blame on the citizens filing the suit and the ones that voted for city/ manager. We have lost so much in this town because the mayor & city council will not pay attention to what the voters want. Why would any businesses want to locate here when there is no activities for the business owners and employees families to do. Also we are talking about minimum wage jobs that will be offered while the city gives MILLIONS of city tax dollars that take away money from our schools and roads. Don’t believe me, just drive down the few roads that lead to our hospital, high school and middle school that are all within a few blocks of each other. I would hate to be seriously wounded on the back of an ambulance on these roads.

  • Gia

    You all need to get with the program; it’s call development. The City requires growth in its infastructure, census population growth, requires more businesses, which will provide employment. And yes we need to pay TAXES… how else do we improve! I can’t stand the fact that I have to drive 50 miles to any amenity. So STOP the wining and move on with development and support your local council..

Comments are closed.